CAD To Remain Under Pressure in 2016 with Softer Commodity Prices
The Canadian dollar struggled in 2015 and was the worst performer amongst major pairs. The USD advanced 20 percent versus the CAD since the beginning of 2015 driven by the divergence of monetary policies between the two central banks and the drop in commodity prices. As a commodity currency the Loonie suffered downward pressure from the drop in oil prices as the crude supply glut drove prices to multi year lows coupled with the low appetite for gold in 2015. A new Prime Minister was voted into office whose campaign was focused on fiscal stimulus brings hope for the Canadian economy, but also the risk of growing the deficit in times of uncertainty.
The fate of the Canadian dollar is joined at the hip with the price of oil and minerals. Statistics Canada puts the contribution of oil, gas and mining to upwards of 27% of gross domestic product (GDP). It is also the most volatile component as the price of other goods is not likely to change as much as their valuations are not expected to face the same pricing factors than those anticipated in the oil industry.
The Canadian economy is facing multiple headwinds starting with the emerging market slowdown, which hit commodity prices, and the rate divergence trends that keep the currency under pressure until there are indeed higher rates. The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) unchanged production levels have had far reaching implications for the price of oil. Saudi Arabia is pumping at record levels to keep gaining market share versus competitors. The resulting supply glut has flooded the market and has the price of West Texas oil below $30 in the first weeks of the year.
The loonie must remain low to give a chance of economic recovery via competitive export prices but do so at a moderate pace to avoid triggering inflation beyond the central bank target. How to accomplish that gradual depreciation is something the Bank of Canada and multiple analysts are pondering as the variables keep changing.
Interest Rate Divergence to Help BoC Targets
After cutting the benchmark Canadian interest rate two times in 2015 to record low 0.50 percent the BoC Governor admitted for the first time near the end of the year that negative rates could be added to the monetary policy toolkit. Governor Poloz remains firm that the central bank has the right growth forecast on the Canadian economy, but the weakness of energy prices have expanded the time horizon for recovery. The most positive factor to Canada’s recovery is the U.S. economic recovery that trimmest a start of a monetary policy tightening cycle. Canada is well positioned to boost exports to its largest trading partner, but depends heavily on the sustained growth of the U.S. to recover and the price of energy.
The BoC was one of the most proactive central banks this year cutting the benchmark rate twice in an effort to devalue the loonie ahead of a drop in the price of crude and give exporters a chance to offset the losses in the energy sector. The U.S. Federal Reserve has finally hiked the U.S. interest rate giving some breathing room to the BoC as the effects of that monetary policy decision are still working their way through the market.
The monetary policy divergence will pressure the CAD as it heads lower versus the USD in 2016. The Canadian economy fell into a technical recession after the second quarter results, but managed to bounce back in the third quarter after strong consumer demand. Softer economic data is threatening to record another contraction as commodity prices keep falling with lower demand and vast supply in the market.
New Government Facing Challenging Economic Landscape
The Liberal party of Canada won a majority in parliament after the longest election campaign in modern Canadian history. Prime Minister elect Justin Trudeau was able to come back from a third place in polls at the beginning of the race to a win that seemed unlikely given the 2011 elections that left the party decimated.
The Finance Department announced the new Liberal government is facing a deteriorating economy that has turned the projected Conservative surplus plans into a deficit in reality. This is all before the Liberals follow through in their promised stimulus to add a strong pace to the recovery. The Liberal budget will be released in March and is expected to show a commitment to investment in infrastructure and job creation that will put Canada in a deficit with the intention to boost growth.
The Liberal platform was built on fiscal stimulus and Mr. Morneau has reiterated that it is the only way that Canada will achieve faster growth. The Canadian economy is still under the effects of lower oil prices, while the loonie drop has not been able to boost exports to the point where it can offset the losses in the energy sector.
Canadian Oil Fate Tied to Global Growth
The Canadian economy enjoyed stability after the credit crisis thanks to the price of oil remaining above $100 until the summer of 2014. The sudden and continued drop to current levels of under $30 has taken out of the equation the strongest contributor to the Canadian economy. Trade agreements and a strong currency uprooted the manufacturing base in Canada and now with energy exports compromised the service industry will have to step up to offset losses. The Bank of Canada is expecting the weak loonie to help exporters increase their competitiveness. The oil industry was dealt another blow with the rejection of the Keystone pipeline that could have made it possible for producers to export their oil to further destinations other than the traditional American clients. The U.S. is now considering exporting its oil surplus reversing a decision from decades ago, while Canadian crude is to remain landlocked with no access to shipping ports. The price war between OPEC and non-OPEC members with Saudi Arabia and Russia as the most combative (and largest) oil producers could see energy prices drop to new lows as demand is not expected to grow fast enough to soak up all the excess crude currently in the market.
This year will mark the return of Iranian oil to the market after the sanctions were lifted. Iran holds the fourth largest oil reserves in the world and has issued plans of producing 500,000 daily oil barrels. With OPEC and non-OPEC producers hitting record production levels the price of oil will continue to suffer from a supply glut as more worries rise on emerging market demand on crude oil.
Russia and China Central Banks to Support Gold Prices
Gold had a net negative year in 2015. The central banks of China and Russia along with Indian demand were the largest purchasers of gold this year keeping gold in current levels as global demand has shrunk. China and India account for two thirds of the global demand for gold. Chinese and Indian demand fell 25% and 3% respectively, but given the low prices there is room for opportunistic buys as investors in those nations look for alternative asset classes.
Global gold consumption dropped 12% in the second half of 2015, to six-year low, as key buyers in Asia lost their appetite for the metal. One buyer who has moved against the tide is the People’s Bank of China (PBoC) which has increased its gold reserves to 1,743 tons by the end of November. The central banks of China and Russia have increased their holdings and kept the price of gold from crashing below $1,000.
The fact that western central banks usually hold about 60 percent of reserves in gold compared to the paltry 1.6 percent of China translates to an assurance of further demand if the price continues to trade in the current range as the PBoC looks to diversify its reserves.
Gold Producers Have FX Silver Lining
With the price of gold dangerously close to $1,000 mining stocks are big losers as they have been forced to cut back to survive the reduction in revenue due to falling prices. There is a psychological level that gets mentioned that producers need at least $1,200 per ounce to break even on extraction costs. Mines located in emerging markets will provide better results due to the effect of a weaker currency on operating costs. With softer demand outside of the central banks of Russia and China forecasted the mining industry would have to seek further consolidations and find ways to reduce costs as it strives to survive another challenging year. Canadian mining companies that have invested in sites in emerging markets could get some cost savings both on operating and head office costs as the Canadian dollar is expected to be under pressure next year.
The greenback has rallied strongly against its Canadian counterpart this year, breaking above 1.40 last week for the first time since July 2003. Despite this, the pair is showing signs of exhaustion and given the Fed’s dovish tone after hiking rates last week, I do wonder if the pair may be primed for correction. The bearish divergence between price and the MACD suggests the rally is now lacking momentum, which could support my suspicions. Any correction could see the pair run into support around 1.34 initially, being prior resistance but also having additional assistance from, the ascending trend line – 15 May lows. Below here we also have the ascending trend line from the September lows followed by 1.28 which was a key level during the pair’s ascent. A move below here may indicate a more bearish fundamental shift. If we do see a continuation of the move above 1.40, then 1.46 may off some reprieve having been support back in March 2003, followed by 1.50, prior support and resistance and a key psychological level.